Phoenicia’s Mama’s Boy Market is Closing

Nov. 30 will mark a sad day for the Ulster County hamlet of Phoenicia: Mama’s Boy Market, a popular cafe, coffee shop and local hangout, will shut its doors after losing its lease.

Founder and owner Michael Koegel posted the news on Facebook this morning, along with a host of heartfelt thank yous, including to his neighbors and customers, “the amazing, wacky people of Phoenicia, who supported my little enterprise because they knew that by supporting small businesses like mine they were contributing to the growth of their own community.”

“It’s been a great adventure here in Phoenicia, and the adventure continues just a few miles up route 214,” Koegel said.

Koegel’s second Catskill restaurant, Mama’s Boy Burgers in Tannersville, will remain open.

Mama’s Boy Market was a fixture in Phoenicia for more than five years. Photo by Catskill Eats

Here is more from Koegel’s post:

I’d like to thank all of you for five and a half years of support and friendship. Some people told me I was crazy to open a coffee shop in Phoenicia. But then others, strangers, would see me outside working on the renovation or picking up debris and call out “Thank you!” for doing something with this derelict lot in the middle of town. That’s when I knew I was doing the right thing. 

I hobbled this place together out of found objects and converted that tiny little shack into a a bit of an icon (or eyesore, depending on your POV). I put my heart and soul into Mama’s Boy and for every ounce of effort I put in, you matched it with your kindness and support. This place kept me going for five years, and on the 5th anniversary of opening the coffee shop, I opened Mama’s Boy Burgers in Tannersville. if it wasn’t for the good people of Phoenicia, Mama’s Boy Burgers would never have happened.

I learned a great deal along the way, made a lot of new friends in the community and started a new life in this coolest small town. And Phoenicia isn’t the place it was 5 years ago; if I had any part of that at all, I’m as proud as hell.

Want more Catskill Eats? Please join us on FacebookTwitter and Instagram for breaking news and more photos. Got a tip to offer? Drop us a line here.